The Question About Whether You’d Like To Hear An Adele and Beyoncé Collaboration

The Question About Whether You’d Like To Hear An Adele and Beyoncé Collaboration

Originally published on madamenoire.com

With the addition of Rihanna and Taylor Swift (based on sales and influence), I would say that the most powerful women in music are Beyoncé and Adele. Their fans cover all age groups. Their fans are also very diverse. And whenever these ladies drop new music, as Beyoncé said, “world stop…”

And both women have expressed their admiration of one another publicly. When speaking of Adele’s voice, Beyoncé reportedly compared it to “listening to God.” And Adele has talked about how thinking of Beyoncé’s famous alter ego helped her get through performance anxiety: “What would Sasha Fierce do?”

So you could probably understand why some were puzzled by rumors that spread earlier this month that the British singer turned down the opportunity to sing alongside Beyoncé on a track.

According to an interview with Beats 1’s Zane Lowe, Adele was also puzzled by that report.

“There’s a rumor going round that I turned Beyoncé down. I’d never disrespect her like that,” she said. “I’m such a fan, oh my god [sic]. Obviously, like, Queen Bey to the day I die.”

And while you won’t hear a collaboration with Mrs. Carter on Adele’s 25, it sounds like a joint effort could be on the way soon enough.

Can’t say I want to hear it, though. And I say that as a fan of both women.

Honestly, I just don’t know if it’s necessary. More than anything, I just think their voices and music are completely different, and those same voices may not complement one another very well on a track. Adele is a powerhouse all about her sweeping ballads and Beyoncé, while also vocally gifted, is about everything else: The swag, the sex, the party anthems and joints that start a movement (i.e., how “Flawless” had everyone saying, “I woke up like this”). What exactly would they put together? “Who Run The World (Girls) Pt. II”?

And while I am a Beyoncé fan, I often wonder if she collaborates with certain people these days not because she really wants to, but because they are the individuals everyone is talking about–and who happen to be soaking up a lot of the spotlight that she’s used to. Like the two times she collaborated with Lady Gaga when Gaga’s career was on fire (that “Video Phone” remix was all over the place). Or her recent collaborations with Nicki Minaj on “Feeling Myself” and the “Flawless” remix. Considering that Adele is the darling of mainstream music (“Hello” set records in no time, and is the fastest song to hit No.1 on the radio since Mariah Carey’s “Dreamlover” in ’93), it would make sense to team up with the singer. There is a lot of power behind her name, and she also happens to be well-liked by damn near everybody. Working with people who are hot, keeps you cooking too.

But more than anything, I don’t think everyone needs to collaborate on everything. Case in point: Eddie Murphy getting Michael Jackson to sing on “Whatzupwithu.” DMX collaborating with Marilyn Manson on “The Omen.” That random time the Jonas Brothers sang alongside Common for “Don’t Charge Me For The Crime.” Or the uncomfortable time Beyoncé sang “Irreplaceable” with Sugarland at the American Music Awards. All of these were efforts that left you asking “Why?”

Some musicians do their best work on their own, especially those known for their voice. Like a Sade. Or an Amy Winehouse. And yes, an Adele. Once they start working with other people (as in performing on a track together, not production), it’s a trap. One collabo turns into one of many. Artists end up attempting to keep up with the other individual’s mannerisms and sounds. And in the end, the song ends up leaning toward one artist more than another. And I’m sorry, but I don’t want to hear Adele trying to keep up and sound like Bey, and I don’t want to hear Beyoncé trying to sound like or keep up with Adele. If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.

So while I love the support they offer one another and that both of these powerful women have no problem expressing their fandom for the other, that’s enough for me.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Previous Zachary Quinto Stopped Going To Church When He Realized He Was Gay
Next JAMES’ JOURNAL (Entry 52)

About author

You might also like

The Happenings 13 Comments

To Be An 82-Year-Old On Grindr

Originally published on vice.com If there’s one thing gay men recognize about their milieu, it’s the rather severe ageism that pervades it. Profiles on sex sites often set strict guidelines

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
The Happenings 34 Comments

Boy Next Door’s Ryan Guzman Strips for Cancer Research

I just love it when celebrities attempt to get us to focus on certain grave issues by getting naked, just as I’m focusing on actor Ryan Guzman and all the

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
The Happenings 4 Comments

Elton John says LGBT Africans must not be left behind in fight against HIV

Sir Elton John has said resources must be focused on reaching out to LGBT people in Africa. The Rocketman singer spoke at the major HIV conference in Durban, South Africa,

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

17 Comments

  1. façade
    November 22, 05:30 Reply

    It’s gonna be so awkward, Adele n Beyoncé? Nah! Not gonna be good. I can’t even imagine it

  2. jaja
    November 22, 06:11 Reply

    I feel this dismissal is rushed and prescriptive. A song like “Halo” is common ground for both: they could do something similar. and who says Bey would sound out of place on Someone Like You. Production WON’t lean towards any of them. Please give us Rihanna-Beyonce, Rihanna-Katy, Rihanna-Kesha-Katy, and yes, that Holy Trinity thing

  3. #Chestnut
    November 22, 07:40 Reply

    Well, no one would have thought of Rihanna and Shakira together…(or D’banj and Idris Elba),but here we are. Adele/Beyonce just might work; I’m sure their experts production teams could find a song that caters to their individual styles. Oh,they could do a mash-up of “Hello”(Bey) and #Hello(Adele)!…lol. ok bye.

    OAN: dis Madame Noire go like amebo wella…

    • Mandy
      November 22, 09:00 Reply

      No be small amebo. Tufia

  4. wahid
    November 22, 07:48 Reply

    Hell NO! Queen Bey can’t rule forever. Adele shldnt agree to dis rumoured collab. See wat she did to Shakira wif d ‘beautiful liar’ collab?

    • #Chestnut
      November 22, 08:18 Reply

      *Gasps* @Dennis: how dare you,Dennis?! HOW DARE YOU?!!!

    • Mandy
      November 22, 09:00 Reply

      Oh look! Dennis and Chizzie agreed on something. Adele, quick, call Beyoncé for a collabo. We want two KDians unified in their distaste for your project.

  5. tarter
    November 22, 09:30 Reply

    such myopic view,Beyonce and adele can work on ballads together, obviously nothing catchy or pop,songs like i was here,halo,stop sign,disappear,if i were a boy,heaven,smash into you are Beyonce songs Adele will slay,songs like someone like you,hello,set fire to the rain are Adele’s song bey can also slay.. just that bey doesn’t have much emotions while singing..

      • Peak
        November 23, 14:03 Reply

        Well, we would need to thoroughly trash out and visit the crop of artists you consider as vocalists, before having any futher discussion. You are either clueless about what you are talking about or you are just arguing sideways for the fun of it. Beyoncé is hardly a vocalist? Lol the things I hear on KD.

        • Pink Panther
          November 23, 14:18 Reply

          Peak, leave DM be. I’ve come to see his scorn of Beyoncé as the rantings of a gay Nigerian…

          You know, the type that doesn’t know very much.

          • Max
            November 23, 15:30 Reply

            *stifled laughter*

  6. Max
    November 23, 15:29 Reply

    They might work well together, but I’m not fantasizing about it. They’re both good at what they do individually.

  7. bruno
    November 23, 17:06 Reply

    as much i love bey, most of here collaborations have been decidedly mediocre. “telephone” is an exception though.

    heard she is featured on coldplay’s upcoming album. ugh

Leave a Reply