Italy Approves Same-Sex Civil Unions
After decades of struggle by gay rights groups, and months of contested political negotiations, the Italian Parliament on Wednesday evening gave final approval to a law recognizing civil unions of same-sex couples.
The vote — 372 to 51, with 99 abstentions — was followed by long applause in the Chamber of Deputies, the lower house of Parliament. At the Trevi Fountain in Rome, people with rainbow flags gathered to celebrate.
It was a historic occasion for a nation that is still dominated by the Roman Catholic Church, which opposed the measure, and where traditional family norms are still strong. It was also a victory for Prime Minister Matteo Renzi, who supported the bill.
Nearly every Western country has legalized same-sex marriage or some form of civil union for gays and lesbians. Italy was perhaps the most prominent exception, and the issue has generated considerable controversy.
Proponents of same-sex unions have complained that the law falls short of granting full equality to same-sex couples. In particular, it does not recognize same-sex marriages. It will not allow someone in a same-sex civil union to legally adopt his or her partner’s biological child. A so-called stepchild adoption provision was opposed by center-right parties and by the church and was ultimately dropped from the legislation.
The Senate approved the bill in February, but a final vote in the lower house was required for the legislation to take effect. Earlier on Wednesday, the government won a vote of confidence, 369 to 193, that it had called on Tuesday, tying its fate to the legislation.
Advocates called the lower house decision historic.
“The wall erected mostly by the Vatican against civil rights in this country has fallen, so it is a historically and politically important moment,” said Franco Grillini, the honorary president of Arcigay, an advocacy group, and a gay-rights advocate. At the same time, same-sex couples in Italy wanted marriage equality, a right held by their counterparts in the United States and many Western European countries, and he said that struggle would continue.
It has been nearly 30 years since lawmakers first proposed giving legal recognition to civil unions in Italy. The Vatican under Pope Francis, while expressing more liberal positions on some social issues, has kept up steadfast opposition to legal recognition of same-sex couples, influencing some italian lawmakers.
Mr. Renzi pledged early on that his government would right what was widely seen as an injustice. There was pressure, too, from the European Court of Human Rights, which ruled last July that Italy’s failure to recognize same-sex unions violated the European Convention on Human Rights.
A first draft of the law — it also grants certain new civil rights, like access to public housing, to all unmarried couples, including heterosexual ones — was watered down when the Senate adopted it in February, after it lost the support of a crucial party faction, and the government had to scramble for votes among more conservative lawmakers. The scrapping of the stepchild adoption clause was part of the resulting compromise.
Some scholars said the controversy revealed Italian lawmakers to be more conservative than their constituents.
“The Italian population metabolized the recognition of same-sex couples some time ago,” said Chiara Saraceno, a noted sociologist who retired as a professor of sociology at the University of Turin, citing a 2009 study that confirmed that a “wide majority” of Italians favored legal recognition of same-sex partnerships, though not gay marriage.
Italian lawmakers “have always lagged behind when it comes to family issues,” Professor Saraceno said, whether because of traditionalist viewpoints or fear of irritating the church. “The Italian population is ready for this,” she said of the legislation.
While many supporters said on Wednesday that the new law was better than nothing, many remained bitter.
“This law is born as an old law, that should have been voted 20 years ago,” when civil unions began to be legally recognized in other countries, said Michela Marzano of the Democratic Party, who noted the law’s shortcomings.
“Italy remains a culturally backward country where the only possible family” is still the traditional one, she said. “It prefers to penalize children rather than recognize the multifaceted families that already exist.”
President Sergio Mattarella has a month to sign the legislation, a step that is usually a formality.
About author
You might also like
Woman overhears gay man calling his boyfriend “daddy” and wonders “Isn’t that creepy and maybe perverse?”
A woman overheard a gay man talking about his “daddy” at a party and didn’t understand what he meant, so she’s written a letter to gay advice columnist Hank Scott asking him to explain.
Idris Elba’s Response to the James Bond Casting Rumors
So following the Sony email hack which revealed that the studio bosses are considering Idris Elba to play 007 when Daniel Craig’s contract elapses, there has been quite a furor
Prince William Says He Would Support His Child If They Were Gay
Prince William has said he would “fully support” his children if they were gay, also admitting that he would “worry” about the added pressures they would face. It was something
14 Comments
Delle
May 13, 11:38If Italy can do this, why can’t Nigeria?
keredim
May 13, 11:47@Delle, is that a serious question?
ambivalentone
May 13, 11:48My dear, the demons holding tightly to her common sense are not in the same league with the Catholic church of Italy o
OAN Those two guys in the pics are annoyingly sexy. Why me LAWD???
Mandy
May 13, 11:56It’s not just you o, Ambi. They look like tall, husky drinks of cappucino.
Delle
May 13, 12:06If someone had told me prior to this moment that Italy (home of the catholic faith) would one day legalise same-sex marriage, I prolly would have walked out on the individual so as not to get infected by his stupidity and naiivety.
Very soon, Nigeria would be the only country in the world that doesn’t approve of homosexuality. I see it happening (when Mugabe dies of course).
pete
May 13, 12:25Delle, Israel the home of the 3 biggest religions have a gay pride in Tel Aviv.
Keredim
May 13, 13:44@Delle, you and Mugabe sef…
Are you a Gerontophile?
I am not judging o!
????
Santa Diaba
May 13, 11:47I now know why I love spaghetti and pizza. Viva italia ???
Mandy
May 13, 11:55The thing is, Africa is fighting a losing battle as far as LGBT is concerned. Whether this continent likes it or not, we will be dragged, kicking and screaming as the case may be, to the point where acceptance will be for every gay man and woman.
Keredim
May 13, 12:36Too true Mandy. The Protestant Church synod want to recognise same – sex marriage. But the African faction, led by Nigeria of course, have threatened to leave the synod, If the it votes to recognise same sex marriages.
Khaleesi
May 13, 15:20Italy home of the ‘holy’ Roman Catholic Church and Israel where much of their 4000year old book of fairytales is set, has followed the path of equality, but as usual Nigeria is busy mucking around in the dark, arresting gays in Edo and everywhere else in the land they can trap & capture them … Tufiakwa ***spits&stomps on the Nigerian flag***”
pete
May 13, 19:31You know disrespecting the national flag is an offence?
Shar
May 13, 20:28*Pours kerosene on Nigerian flag and sets it ablaze* eheee now I’m satisfied *walks away swinging hips*
Lorde
May 13, 22:48Lol where’s the chill