An Open Letter To Christians Who Believe That Sexuality Is A Decision

An Open Letter To Christians Who Believe That Sexuality Is A Decision

01-writing-a-letterWritten by John Pavlovitz, originally published on

History is no guarantee of legitimacy.

Thinking sustained over time doesn’t always equal Truth; sometimes it just equals tradition.

Just because many religious people get something wrong over and over and over again, doesn’t eventually one day make it right.

In fact, when it comes to things that we come to believe corporately as a people, sometimes history and tradition and religion are the enemy of progress. We become intellectually lazy; wrong but comfortable in that wrong-ness and unwilling to dig deeper.

Ever since Christians have been talking about homosexuality, many have been trying to begin with an assumption that is simply incorrect and dangerous; that it’s something that all gay people choose.

Here’s part of a conversation between myself and a blog reader; a straight Christian man who was repeatedly, rather matter-of-factly, and quite judgmentally telling gay people that their sexual orientation was simply a choice; a willful decision, (and because of that he reasoned, a decision to sin).

It’s an all-too familiar song sung to the LGBT community by the religious community.

He did what so many well-meaning but misguided straight people of faith do: try to tell a gay person how their hearts work.

On a comment thread where literally hundreds of people had previously talked about their own experience as LGBT, many of them Christians; (trying for decades to deny and change and pray away what was so clearly inherent in them), this man simply refused to listen. I don’t think he was doing this to purposefully hurt them or shut down the conversation, he was simply trying to protect a part of his faith that was being threatened by actual people’s experience to the contrary.

After watching the discussion devolve into a series of predictable religious sound bites, I jumped in and we shared this exchange:

Reader: Sexuality is a choice.

Me: When did you choose heterosexuality?

Reader: I made my choice as a teenager when I started to date girls.

Me: Were you ever sexually or physically attracted to boys, or are you now?

Reader: No, never.

Me: Not really much of a choice then, is it? A choice implies different possible options. But dating guys wasn’t ever really an option for you, was it? If you had been attracted to men, but began dating women anyway, then your sexuality would have been a choice. As it is, you simply went with what felt completely right and natural, rather than with what would have been disgusting and distasteful to your sensibilities. It was a consenting to instinct, not a decision in opposition to it.

I went on to share with this man, a devout Christian, what I want to share with those of you who echo his views on sexuality as a choice; with as much compassion and care and understanding as I can:

I feel for you, and I’m sorry, but I think you’re wrong.

I’ve been a pastor for 18 years, and been shoulder-to-shoulder and face-to-face with thousands of wonderful, God-loving men and women, who were and are living an inherited lie: the lie that gay (or straight) people can choose the objects of their affections and the inclinations of who they love.

You may not believe me when I tell you this, but I understand.

I know well, the difficult spot that you’re in as a believer.

I know that if you can believe that homosexuality is indeed a choice, it can allow you to feel negativity or judgment or disapproval toward gay people without guilt—but for the vast majority of people who identify as LGBT it isn’t a choice, but simply an acceptance of what is most real and most true.

As a straight person, you can disagree with that statement if you’d like, but know that when you do, you’re not being honest with how your own heart works and how you yourself have experienced attraction, and affection, and love, and the desire for intimacy with another.

I know as a Christian, how hard you’re straining to believe this old lie, and the tug-of-war that is happening in your spirit as you fight for an idea you may not quite have peace with anymore.

I know that you’re desperately holding on to a damaging prejudice, despite so much evidence in the face of it, because you really need that prejudice to reinforce the faith perspective you’ve grown-up with and grown comfortable with; and the one you feel you need to keep in order to please God.

To abandon that assumption, would threaten the huge house of cards that would get exposed to the breezes of a billion follow-up questions in its wake.

I understand this, I truly do.

But this idea of anyone choosing who they love, an idea that so many Christians hold so tightly to;

It’s simply not real.

It’s a fake truth dressed up as religion.

It’s a counterfeit license to discriminate in the name of God.

People are lives, not lifestyles.

There is no such thing as a “gay lifestyle”, any more than there is a “heterosexual lifestyle”. (Other than romantic/sexual activity, just how do you define the lifestyle you lead as a straight person?)

In this world, there are only people; there are simply human beings, some who are straight and some who are not.

It’s just the simple, stark, unadorned truth of our shared humanity, regardless of how it messes with our religious convictions or makes us uneasy.

Many people are not made heterosexual, and they can’t be made into one.

Each of us has within us desires to be known and cared for and loved, that are all far beyond what we can steer or alter. You know this, because you’ve experienced it all yourself. To tell a non-heterosexual person that they could and should somehow be convinced to choose the opposite of what their hearts say, would be to suggest that you, a heterosexual person; with enough pressure and cajoling and therapy, could possibly be convinced to be gay. (I imagine this would be an insulting proposition to most of you).

Straight, Christian friend, you can feel any way you care to about those who identify as LGBT, but you’ll need to develop your faith perspective in light of this truth about them. You can build any case you want against non-heterosexual people, but you simply can’t have choice as a weapon in your arsenal.

If you argue that gay people are making a decision regarding their sexuality, you’re essentially not accepting the logic of your own journey and history, and you’re expecting them all to make an emotional sacrifice that you haven’t ever had to make.

That’s a problem.

That’s not loving your neighbor as yourself.

That’s not the Golden Rule.

I’m pretty sure that’s not of Jesus, either.

But don’t take my word for it. After all, I’m still just another straight Christian guy talking about gay people, and that’s definitely not the solution here. We’ve had far too much of that, for far too long in the Church.

Here’s a suggestion: The next time you encounter another adult who tells you that they’re not heterosexual, ask them whether it is their choice or not, and however they respond, have the decency and respect to believe that their understanding of their own heart, is more trustworthy than your evaluation of it from a distance.

If they tell you it’s a choice, then for them, it’s a choice—but not simply because you would like it to be. If they tell you they’ve felt this way since their earliest memories, trust that they know better than you about their reality.

Millions of LGBT people, many of them just teenagers, are being damaged, wounded, and some are quite literally dying, trying to bear the oppressive heaviness of this assumption of choice that we’ve placed on them. Frankly, I think the Church needs to own this, and do some of the “loving of the least” we hear Jesus calling his people to.

I know this message may anger you or frustrate you, or make you want to dig your heels even more deeply into the assumptions you’ve lived in for so long, but I pray you won’t. I pray you’ll ask some really tough questions about what you’ve believed about sexuality, and what you know about your own experience.

And I hope that you won’t just accept the answers you think you know.

We Christians talk about “speaking the truth in love” an awful lot, and even though you may not believe it, I can only tell you that I share this truth, with all the love I have; for you who are trying earnestly to reconcile a faith that you care so deeply about, balanced with the love I have for the LGBT community, who are trying to live authentically and peacefully alongside you in community—and being injured by you.

They are testifying with their words and their hearts, that they did not ask to be born compelled to love as they do, anymore than you or I did. I think they deserve to be heard and listened to; not preached or shouted at.

One of the easiest and least compassionate things we can do in this life is to assume that the way we experience the world, is the way that everyone else does, or should.

We need to do better as a people of faith, at seeing gay people (and all people for that matter) as they are, not as we desire them to be. Our faith after all, claims that all people are made in God’s image, not in our own.

Christian, maybe you’re right; maybe love is indeed a choice, but just not in the way you’ve always thought.

In a very real and tangible way, you may need to choose who and how you love.

Previous The Delights Of ‘How To Get Away With Murder’
Next I Watched And Waited

About author

You might also like

Our Stories 13 Comments


The chat on Grindr lacked chemistry. It was enough reason for me not to further our interaction beyond an online space. But sometimes, you never know. He was consistent in

Editor's Desk 5 Comments

“I Will Fight For You But…” The Shame Of The LGBT Activist

The post you’re yet to read is very contextual. Without revealing much, especially considering the group’s terms of security, there exists on Facebook a group for Nigerian men. In this

Our Stories 62 Comments

An Open Letter To Ageist Gay Men

This piece was originally published on * Dear Ageist Gays, George Bernard Shaw famously wrote “Youth is wasted on the young.” If you don’t understand what this means, then


  1. goodboy
    December 09, 09:25 Reply

    In other news, A gay guy was murdered in abuja garki here last thursday in his hotel room….. *sad*

  2. Kryss S
    December 09, 09:28 Reply

    “They are testifying with their words and their hearts, that they did not ask to be born compelled to love as they do, anymore than you or I did. I think they deserve to be heard and listened to; not preached or shouted at.”

    Lovely piece! Listen! Think! Understand! Is that too hard to get! I get tired of this argument nd it rilli gets to me! Just left my Fb inbox where I was chatting with this my “gay” friend who thinks what he is doing is a GAME nd it rilli doesn’t matter! I was like “y would u keep playing a game most ppl hate? Y would I keep playing a game I have to hide to play? Y would I keep playing a game that has a 14yrs penalty when caught?”. It doesn’t just make sense @ all! It is not a game! It is not a choice! If it were a choice, I would not b here by now! U think I don’t want to hold hands in public with my lover, giggle in eatry together while getting cozy, put on dps on our bdays or even visit each other without raised eyebrows! I do! Am so so tired of this perception, it is frustrating!

    • Max
      December 09, 10:23 Reply

      I’m with you on that… I hate people who think it’s just a game.. They’re still mentally trapped in the lie… The thousnad year old lie humans have been telling themselves..

  3. Handsomely Inclined
    December 09, 10:27 Reply

    People think its a fairytale when a grown man tells you how he fells
    But its not a fairytale when a book written by dessert dwellers told you a snake spoke?
    It’s perfectly ok for a donkey to talk?
    Its not fable when a man walked on water?
    You can identify with a wooden staff turning into a serpent?
    Its not a fairytale for a Man to feed hundreds with just 3 loaves and how many fishes?
    Remind me!
    But when a grown man tells you he doesn’t have any feelings for the opposite sex,it’s unbelievable and a fable?

    Let them keep living in self denial.

  4. Khaleesi
    December 09, 10:53 Reply

    Wow! I so thoroughly love and respect this man! Its sad but I’ve long since given hope on any change in the attitude of Nigerians, they (including many who r gay/bi), have homophobia written deeply in indelible ink into their DNA, the day i realised that i was gay and its what i am naturally and there’s nothing wrong with that is the day a lot of things changed for/with me …
    Great great piece, if only we had just a few who were like this man in our society …

    • pinkpanthertb
      December 09, 11:17 Reply

      In our society…
      You mean the world at large, eh Khaleesi. Cos wishing for such a pastor to exist in Nigeria is…well, wishful thinking

  5. gad
    December 09, 18:04 Reply

    “He did what so many well-meaning but misguided straight people of faith do…” Can one find a more noble man? imagine his maturity! He didn’t resort to name calling or foul language to drive home his point. Even in his disagreement he assessed the other side fairly. How I wish we have more people like this amongs us. The world would have been different by now as far as same sex relationships are concerned

  6. Mr Kassy
    December 10, 16:18 Reply

    I just love this man,he is an epitome of wisdom and fair judgement.I could remember vividly the day I was made to stand in front of a large congregated pentecostal church members to say I am gay:simply becausee they thought I was possesed and wanted to deliver me.The deliverance actuaLly took place for three consecutive days.But after the deliverance I was still gay,and here I am.I WAS BORN THIS WAY.I was having the feelings since I knew my left from my right.And before I forget,I also went to countless churches and prayer places just to get delivered;including a monastery.I wish I can marry a man.I will be the happiest person in this Planet earth.

Leave a Reply