JK Rowling gets slammed with transphobia accusations, for defending a feminist fired for anti-trans views
Harry Potter author JK Rowling has voiced her support for a woman who pursued legal action to have “gender-critical views” protected under the UK Equalities Act.
The writer, 54, hasn’t tweeted since September, but made a surprise return to come out in support for Maya Forstater, who was plunged into a landmark case which tested whether anti-trans views would be considered as a protected characteristic under the 2010 Equalities Act.
Forstater’s employer, the Centre for Global Development, had hired her on a series of short-term contracts as a researcher which were not renewed after a dispute about her tweet in September 2018 which said: “Men cannot change into women.”
Forstater branded it as a “feminist test case” on her Twitter, but judges ultimately ruled that such views would not be protected. A ruling welcomed by many LGBT+ activists.
Following the outcome, Rowling expressed her support for Forstater, inciting a wave of backlash from trans folk and allies alike, accusing Rowling of “transphobia”.
Rowling had tweeted: “Dress however you please. Call yourself whatever you like. Sleep with any consenting adult who’ll have you. Live your best life in peace and security. But force women out of their jobs for stating that sex is real?” She then added the hashtags: “#IStandWithMaya #ThisIsNotADrill.”
She was announcing her support of Forstater after judges stated that “gender-critical” views – a phrase often deployed to defend trans-exclusionary feminism– are “not worthy of respect in a democratic society”.
This came in the heels of Rowling formerly coming under fire for following a “proud transphobe” on Twitter, while also liking a series of tweets that called trans women “men in dresses.”
While Forstater herself also acknowledged Rowling’s tweet, writing: “We are all crying. This is all I wanted for Christmas”, most of Twitter descended on the writer with a fury, causing her to be a trending topic on Twitter alongside the tag “TERF”.
Countless LGBT+ Twitter users shared their responses to Rowling, with many criticizing her stance, calling it “unacceptable” as well as describing their own “heartbreak” at the beloved children’s book author stating such views.
“This hurt to read,” one user wrote. “The implications of your statement are huge for the trans community. Hogwarts was a shelter for us weirdos and oddballs but it seems we are no longer welcome.”
“Trans people are real. Intersex people are real. Bigotry is very real,” wrote another user. “Denying trans and intersex people’s rights and identities is dangerous and unacceptable.”
Yet another tweeted: “This is SUCH a dangerous precedent to set. Especially now that white supremacism, racism & the far right are gaining power & ground…to contribute to this global culture war against progressive values and LGBTQ communities is totally unacceptable. I implore you reflect.”
Some other reacted with “heartbreak” over the betrayal they perceived the woman who created the Pottermore community had rendered them. One said: “Well, she finally said the quiet part out loud. This is really heartbreaking for a lot of folks. If Harry Potter is ruined for you, I completely get it. I’m going to try to hold onto the magic I’ve found in fandom, the original text, & the magic others have created around it.”
“My daughter, who is trans, is a big fan of yours,” another user said. “It breaks my heart to see you post something indicating that discrimination against her is perfectly fine behaviour for an employee. The world’s most credible medical orgs affirm trans people. Please catch up.”
But not everyone was against Rowling, as some came in defense of her stance.
The one time you say something reasonable and everyone’s canceling you ?
— Blaire White (@MsBlaireWhite) December 19, 2019
Thank you. These are scary times for women who assert their right to recognise objective reality
— Helen Joyce (@HJoyceGender) December 19, 2019
You said nothing wrong. Social media is completely overrun by self-righteous bullies who use social justice as a means to intimidate others—especially women—into silence over this issue.
— Ian Miles Cheong (@stillgray) December 19, 2019
The amount of emotional responses to this tweet exemplifies why this a ridiculous discussion – people thinking their emotions trump facts and logic.
The facts don't change because they offend you.
Biology doesn't cease to exist simply because it hurts your feelings.
— Sydney Watson (@SydneyLWatson) December 20, 2019
About author
You might also like
‘The real world is that with the truth comes judgment.’ – Michelle Rodriguez
Cara Delevingne recently opened up about her sexuality to Vogue, and (rumored) former flame Michelle Rodriguez couldn’t be happier. During the press launch for the Fast & Furious-Supercharged ride at
The Question About Whether You’d Like To Hear An Adele and Beyoncé Collaboration
Originally published on madamenoire.com With the addition of Rihanna and Taylor Swift (based on sales and influence), I would say that the most powerful women in music are Beyoncé and
Rod Daily and Cameron Bay File Lawsuits against Kink.Com for giving them HIV
Former porn models Rod Daily and Cameron Bay have both filed civil suits against their former studio, Kink.com, related to the 2013 scandal in which both of them turned out
4 Comments
Mitch
December 20, 06:57It’s shocking how sense is being eroded on the altar of inclusivity.
How does it make sense to say that you are a different sex inside than your actual biological sex? It becomes especially irritating when trans people and trans activists sacrifice biological sex, which is an observable reality, on the altar of gender that is a social creation.
People can be gender dysphoric, no doubt about that. But that problem exists because of the socially created labels and enforced expectations upon people BASED ON THEIR BIOLOGICAL SEX! The mistake comes from society’s inability to understand that there is no one way to be or to act or to present for any of the sexes.
And that’s what gender-critical feminists are trying to get people to understand. Unfortunately, the trans echo chamber that thrives on senseless rhetoric (read: TWAW) and slamming people who disagree with their views with labels such as transphobic and TERF, will not pay any attention. They get off on attention and bullying others while claiming to be victims.
It’s annoying, all of it.
And, without knowing it, trans affirming LGB activists are eroding the validity of their own communities by supporting this wave of madness.
People are entitled to whatever they want to do. To change their sex, to call themselves by the pronouns of another sex, to do whatever they want really. But what they’re not entitled to are the spaces of the actual owners of the sex they’re changing into. They’re not entitled to their sports, they’re not entitled to their opportunities, and they sure as hell aren’t entitled to their bodies. Or to erasing them to pander to their brand of stupidity.
Like I’ll always say, the patriarchy is a Hydra. Cut off one head and it’d simply morph and sprout 3 more. And, this wave of trans ‘activism’ is clearly one of those heads.
Black Dynasty
December 21, 18:48Sighs, I’m with JK on this. It is ok to disagree with folks whilst being respectful… this is not discrimination.
It is unfortunate that people don’t get that in the name of inclusivity, you cannot force people with threats to have the same viewpoint as you. It is counterproductive…
Opinion: J.K. Rowling Is Taking Heat From the LGBT Left. And The Reason Should Concern Us All – KitoDiaries
January 09, 06:52[…] weeks ago, few could have predicted the fiery backlash that J.K. Rowling, author of the bestselling Harry Potter series, would receive from her own fans. […]
JK Rowling faces backlash over tweets considered transphobic – KitoDiaries
June 07, 09:31[…] has come under fire for voicing similar opinions before. In December, she received backlash for supporting a researcher who lost her job after saying a person cannot change their biological […]